So the fact that I had him the whole time until this issue arose means I was just a "chosen one" before? I uninstalled and reinstalled my game losing everything (before I saw that I should not do this) and when I started playing levels again, saw the screen showing how I "should" get him, but you are saying he only…
If the only requirement is that you beat a level without losing a life, and I beat 5 levels in a row without losing a life, then I should have seen Allen multiple times.