@puppet3 - welcome to our wonderful community! Can you take 2 screen shots next time showing your two choices and then what you actually got? The only time I have received choices I didn't want was when I didn't like one of the choices (having to use boosters) so I chose the one that says Can you handle anything that's thrown at you? If you pick that one - then it could be any of the possible options - including what the other choice was that you didn't choose.
You should get a chance to accomplish the option you choose so if you send the screen shots I can see if I can help you, because I understand your wanting to get the rewards especially since one of them is a hammer. Please tag me when you post the screen shots so I will be notified and can respond to you faster.
Wow, you guys still have that feature of selecting between 2 quests? That disappeared off my game months ago and never returned. lol
@puppet3 Where do you play your game? I mean that feature was only on mobile/app version anyway, and if it's that's where you're playing, at least 10 people are assigned to your game by default. There's like 143 players in my game.