Hello friends. I am posting this here away from view in the off topic section because I really don't want to take the fun out of the competition for all the newbies out there who would not understand my post and only get confused by it all. I'm not sure I will add all my data, but I have loads of it and it all leads to the same conclusion:
We are playing against recordings in the first three All Stars rounds.
I can't believe it's taken me so long to realise this. I started off about a year ago and I have repeatedly checked out previous leaderboard events and always seen the same patterns. One example is this post from August 2025:
Since the AI took over running the game we have seen the same patterns again and again and again in live leaderboard competitions.
I have taken extensive notes on all my accounts and found that players just stop playing for no good reason. There can be no other conclusion than that time is being manipulated by the app. I cannot work out the exact mechanics of it. But the only way I see that this can be done is by making us play against recordings, in much the same way that we know we are playing against recordings in the Episode Races.
The pattern is almost identical as well: One player speeds ahead, often then to be overtaken by a different player, to make it look more realistic. Two players (about 25% of the leaderboard) fail to make any progress at all, or just one or two levels. And then near the end we are allowed to catch up if we want to and get the "win". In the Episode Race this is the top spot. In the Weekly Contest this is a podium place. In All Stars it is a qualifying spot.
In the Weekly Contest and in live leaderboards usually one player is so far ahead we would have to try extremely hard to beat that one player. This one is for the "mad crushers" to pit their skills against and in my two newbie games I am not seeing this in All Stars, probably because I have been playing those accounts slowly: the app thinks I am a genuine newbie who cannot crush any faster so it's giving me all easy opponents I can beat this round. It looks to me like King want every single player who really cares about it to get to the final knockout rounds this year.
The mechanics of how this feat is achieved is not clear but my guess is this: I have noted that it takes two levels to be played for anyone to show up on our leaderboards. When I was first on my leaderboard last night it filled up ever so slowly until I had played my second level as well. So I think the app calculates our own speed and that of others in the first two new levels we play as we join. Those players who show up and then never play another level seem to often have a score of over 200, so it looks to me like they played two levels and then got stuck on the third level. I have also found that near the beginning of the joining process the leaderboard takes a long time to load but after that updates very quickly. This makes me think that data of other players is being loaded and stored onto our devices at the beginning of the round. Possibly at this point the speed of the other players is decided as well, according to parameters of our own playing tactics and level. I suspect that the eventual outcome (the score we will have to beat) is pre determined in the same way that the outcome of the gold we will can win in Candy Royale is pre determined. (We have confirmation from a post made by the CM about two years ago that Candy Royale is recordings). This is my theory and I have ample evidence to support it. I'd be happy for anyone here to disagree. I really don't like the findings but I cannot draw any other conclusion.
What complicates matters is that some of these players on our leaderboards can become our friends, so this shows that they are real and actively playing. However, the recordings may be from an earlier round. Or maybe it's a time-lapse of some sort. That would mean the server would have to update their progress periodically and recalculate the speed of the others - possibly according to how many levels we ourselves have passed or if we have played a multiplier ourselves-, which may be what is happening. Some of the players may be real and some may be older recordings from years ago (such as the ones who stop playing altogether).
I just hope that the final knockout rounds won't be run in this way. I definitely hope that final knockout round 3/3 will be run as fairly as it was last year, with ten leaderboards and players who see one another. We know for a fact this was the case last year. Let's hope it's the same this year.
Good luck to you all!
I'll tag those who might be interested and not find this thread otherwise:
@Alienscar
@GiggzZz
@MannyFae
@Nobody1
@teenybee